Boys PIAA State Champions
2009 – 15-4-1 (2-1 win over Hampton)
1999 – 20-2 (4-1 win over Quaker Valley)

Boys PIAA AA District 1 Champions
2009
1999

Boys Pennsylvania Soccer Coaches Association All State Players
1973 – Ron Yunkin
1974 – Ron Yunkin, Russ Dickinson
1975 – Russ Dickinson
1981 – Joel Buckwalter
1982 – Scott Runge
1988 – Mark Shelton
1999 – Evan Smallwood
2000 – Jeff Chambers
2001 – Ryan Smallwood
2002 – Jeff Chambers
2008 – Nathan Beideman

Boys Region II All-American All Star Team
2000 – Jeff Chambers
2001 – Ryan Smallwood
2002 – Jeff Chambers

Gene Davis Pennslyvania Soccer Coaches Association Coach of the Year
(Gene Davis was an All-American soccer player at West Chester University and the soccer coach at Octorara for 25 years. He also served as a teacher and principal but sadly passed away in 1985 at the age of 47. The PSCA Coach of the Year awards are given in his honor.)

1999 – PIAA AA – Charles “Chip” Smallwood
2009 – PIAA AA – Kevin Noon

Boys Southern Chester County League Championships
1967
1973
1974
1975
1979
1981
1982
1986
1988
1989
1990
1991
1998
2000
2001

Boys Ches-Mont League Divison Championships
2008